The best Pirelli tire overall in this roundup is the Scorpion All Season Plus 3, a versatile SUV and crossover option offered in several listed sizes. For performance-oriented drivers, the P Zero All Season stands out, while motorcycle riders can compare the sport-focused Diablo Rosso II with the touring-minded Angel ST. The right choice depends on vehicle fit, driving style, and whether you prioritize year-round versatility, touring comfort, or sharper handling. These tires are not interchangeable: vehicle category, exact size, and load and speed ratings narrow the field first. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to matching a Pirelli model to your needs.
Get garage and car supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Scorpion All Season Plus 3 appears in four listed sizes, making it the broadest SUV and crossover option in this roundup; confirm each size’s ratings against your vehicle requirements.
- P Zero All Season is the performance-oriented car option, while the Cinturato P7 is the touring-focused alternative; choose by driving priorities rather than model name alone.
- Motorcycle tires serve distinct purposes: Diablo Rosso II is the sport-oriented set, while Angel ST is the more touring-oriented choice.
- The Scorpion Zero All Season and Scorpion STR address different SUV needs from the Scorpion All Season Plus 3, so tread family and intended use matter as much as tire diameter.
- Exact fitment limits the shortlist: the listed tires span multiple vehicle types, sizes, and load or speed ratings, so a promising model is not a match unless its full specification fits.
| Pirelli tire | Load index | Maximum pressure | Rim size | Load capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pirelli Diablo Rosso II Motorc | 58 | 36 psi | 17 inches | 520 pounds |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | 94 | 51 psi | 18 inches | 1,477 pounds |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Perf | 94 | 51 psi | 17 inches | 1,477 pounds |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 Touring R | 91 | 51 psi | 17 inches | — |
| Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Seas | 110 | 50 psi | 21 inches | 2,337 pounds |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | 103 | 44 psi | — | 1,929 pounds |
| Pirelli Angel ST Motorcycle Ti | 58 | 42 pound_per_square_foot | 17 inches | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | 105 | 51 psi | 18 inches | 2,039 pounds |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | 105 | 44 psi | — | 2,039 pounds |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | 114 | 51 psi | 22 inches | 2,601 pounds |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | 105 | 51 psi | 19 inches | 2,039 pounds |
| Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 | 102 | 44 psi | 20 inches | 1,874 pounds |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/ | 94 | 51 psi | 17 inches | 1,477 pounds |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Pirelli Diablo Rosso II Motorcycle Tire Set, 120/70 ZR17 Front and 190/50 ZR17 Rear
The Diablo Rosso II set is the motorcycle pick here for riders who want sport-oriented cornering with some touring versatility. Its dual-compound construction pairs a more durable center with grippier shoulders, so straight-line wear and cornering traction are addressed by different parts of the tread. The asymmetric pattern is designed for wet and dry grip, while the profile targets stability and precise handling under acceleration. Compared with the Angel ST set in this roundup, this option is more clearly aimed at responsive sport riding; the Angel ST’s 180/55 rear size may suit a different motorcycle fitment. The tradeoff is that this is a specific 120/70 front and 190/50 rear pairing, not a universal answer for every bike. Confirm both sizes and the bike’s load and pressure requirements before choosing it.
Pros:- Dual compounds balance center-tread durability with shoulder grip.
- Asymmetric tread is designed for wet and dry traction.
- Profile targets stability and precise cornering response.
- Includes a Pirelli keychain.
Cons:- The set’s specific rear size will not fit motorcycles that require the 180/55 size used by the Angel ST set.
- A year-round design is not a substitute for a tire selected specifically for severe cold or winter riding conditions.
Best for: Sport and touring motorcycle riders whose bikes require a 120/70 ZR17 front and 190/50 ZR17 rear and who want a balance of cornering grip and center-tread durability.
Not ideal for: Riders whose motorcycles require different tire sizes, or those seeking a dedicated winter motorcycle tire rather than a year-round design.
- Front tire size:120/70 ZR17
- Rear tire size:190/50 ZR17
- Rim size:17 inches
- Construction:Radial
- Tread type:Directional
- Load index:58
- Load capacity:520 pounds
- Maximum pressure:36 psi
- Tread depth:7/32 inches
Our verdict“Choose the Diablo Rosso II set if your motorcycle matches its exact sizes and you prioritize sport-oriented cornering with a more durable center tread.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire 235/45R18 94V
This P Zero All Season is the stronger fit for drivers with 18-inch wheels who want an ultra-high-performance tire that can stay on the car through changing seasons. Its circumferential grooves help channel water away, while siping is intended to support cornering and snow traction. The tread is also designed to limit road noise, a useful counterpoint to its performance focus. Compared with the 215/55R17 P Zero All Season in this roundup, this version fits an 18-inch wheel and has a lower-profile size; the right choice depends on the vehicle’s approved fitment, not a general preference for one size. Its all-season label offers more seasonal flexibility than the summer-only Cinturato P7, but it is not a dedicated severe-winter option. Also, RunFlat, PNCS, and SealInside features are limited to select sizes, so do not assume they are included here.
Pros:- All-season tread design supports use across changing weather.
- Circumferential grooves help channel water and reduce hydroplaning risk.
- Siping supports cornering and traction in snow.
- Tread design aims to keep road noise down.
Cons:- RunFlat, PNCS, and SealInside features are available only on select sizes and are not confirmed for this one.
- Its all-season design is not a replacement for a dedicated severe-winter tire.
Best for: Drivers of compatible cars with 235/45R18 fitment who want responsive steering and wet-weather water evacuation in a year-round performance tire.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need a tire explicitly equipped with RunFlat, PNCS, or SealInside features in this size, or who regularly face severe winter conditions.
- Size:235/45R18
- Rim size:18 inches
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Season:Year-round
- Construction:Radial
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Tire diameter:26.34 inches
Our verdict“Pick this P Zero if your car calls for 235/45R18 and you want year-round performance, but verify any specialty construction features before buying.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Performance Tire, 215/55R17 94V
For cars specified for a 17-inch wheel, this 215/55R17 P Zero All Season brings the same performance-minded all-season approach as the 235/45R18 version, but in a distinct fitment. Its ribbed tread is designed to support responsive steering, while grooves and siping help manage wet roads and light snow; the pattern also aims to reduce cabin noise. The 9/32-inch tread depth is slightly less than the 10/32 inches listed for the 18-inch P Zero, though those figures alone do not establish comparative service life. Against the Cinturato P7, this P Zero is the more season-flexible choice because the P7 is listed as a summer tire. The tradeoff is that specialty features such as RunFlat, PNCS, and SealInside are available only on select sizes, with no confirmation that this specific size includes them.
Pros:- Ribbed tread is designed for responsive steering and cornering control.
- Circumferential grooves help move water away from the contact area.
- Siping supports traction in snow and wet conditions.
- Tread pattern is designed to reduce cabin noise.
Cons:- RunFlat, PNCS, and SealInside features are limited to select sizes.
- Its all-season design is not intended to replace a dedicated tire for severe winter conditions.
Best for: Drivers of compatible cars with 215/55R17 fitment who want an all-season tire with responsive steering, wet-road grooves, and some light-snow capability.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose vehicles require an 18-inch fitment, need confirmed RunFlat or noise-cancelling technology on this size, or regularly drive in severe winter weather.
- Size:215/55R17 94V
- Rim size:17 inches
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Season:All-season
- Construction:Radial
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Tire diameter:26.3 inches
Our verdict“Choose this P Zero over the 18-inch version only when 215/55R17 is the correct fitment for your car.”
Pirelli Cinturato P7 Touring Radial Tire, 225/45R17 91Y
The Cinturato P7 is the focused choice for drivers who want a summer tire for a compatible 17-inch car, rather than the wider seasonal range offered by either P Zero All Season option. Its ribbed tread is designed to reduce rolling resistance, which can help limit energy lost as the tire rolls, while deep grooves channel water for wet-road traction. The 225/45R17 size and 91Y rating make vehicle fitment and the car maker’s required specifications essential checks. This is a more season-specific pick than the P Zero models: it is listed for summer use, so it should not be chosen for winter driving. The product information also lists no manufacturer warranty. That omission does not establish the tire’s durability, but buyers who want a stated warranty should compare available terms before deciding.
Pros:- Ribbed tread is designed to reduce rolling resistance.
- Deep grooves help channel water in wet conditions.
- Summer performance focus suits compatible medium- to high-powered cars.
- 225/45R17 fitment serves cars that do not take the 18-inch P Zero size.
Cons:- Summer tire design is not specified for winter use.
- No manufacturer warranty is listed in the supplied product data.
Best for: Drivers of compatible medium- or high-powered cars who want a summer-focused 225/45R17 tire with a tread designed to reduce rolling resistance.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need one tire for year-round use or regularly drive in cold, snowy, or icy conditions; an all-season P Zero is a better match for broader seasonal use.
- Size:225/45R17 91Y
- Rim size:17 inches
- Load index:91
- Season:Summer
- Construction:Radial
- Tread type:Non-directional
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Rim width:7.5 inches
- Tire diameter:24.9 inches
Our verdict“Choose the Cinturato P7 for a compatible car used in warmer seasons, but select an all-season P Zero if you need broader weather coverage.”
Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season 275/45R21 110W XL SUV/Crossover Tire
The Scorpion Zero All Season is the SUV and crossover specialist in this group, with a 21-inch fitment, XL load range, and a 2,337-pound stated load capacity. Its tread and dense siping are designed for dry and wet control plus light-snow traction, while Pirelli’s noise-cancelling system targets a quieter cabin. That comfort feature gives it a different emphasis from the car-focused P Zero All Season tires, which are listed in smaller passenger-car sizes. The Scorpion is a better match for a compatible larger vehicle, not an upgrade that can be chosen by preference alone. Its all-season design does not make it suitable for severe winter conditions, and the product data cautions that universal fit may not suit every vehicle. Check the vehicle placard and wheel specifications before purchase.
Pros:- XL load range and 2,337-pound load capacity suit compatible heavier applications.
- Tread grooves and dense siping support wet, dry, and light-snow traction.
- Noise-cancelling system is designed to reduce road noise.
- 21-inch SUV/crossover fitment distinguishes it from the passenger-car P Zero options.
Cons:- Not designed for severe winter conditions.
- The 21-inch size and vehicle-specific fitment limit compatibility.
- Listed as a tire only, with no additional components included.
Best for: SUV and crossover owners whose vehicles specify 275/45R21 and who want all-season wet and dry performance, light-snow capability, and a quieter ride.
Not ideal for: Drivers of vehicles that do not approve 275/45R21, or owners who need dependable traction in severe winter conditions.
- Size:275/45R21 110W
- Rim size:21 inches
- Load index:110
- Load capacity:2,337 pounds
- Load range:XL
- Maximum pressure:50 psi
- Season:All-season
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Tire diameter:30.75 inches
Our verdict“Choose the Scorpion Zero if your SUV or crossover specifies this 21-inch size and you value quiet all-season road manners over severe-winter capability.”
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 235/60R18 103H SUV/Crossover Tire
I’d choose this Scorpion when the priority is steady all-season touring rather than a sportier steering feel. Its full-depth 3D sipes are designed to support wet, dry, and light-snow traction as the tread wears, while the 70,000-mile warranty gives it a clear durability focus. Compared with the Pirelli P Zero All Season 245/60R18, this model has a narrower 235/60R18 fit and a symmetrical touring tread, favoring everyday crossover use over the P Zero’s emphasis on cornering response. The tradeoff is that its snow capability is for ordinary all-season conditions, not severe winter travel, and the supplied information does not quantify noise or actual tread life. I’d shortlist it for routine commuting, but not for drivers seeking a performance-oriented tire.
Pros:- Full-depth 3D sipes are designed to support traction and braking as the tire wears.
- All-season tread design covers wet, dry, and light-snow driving.
- 70,000-mile manufacturer warranty description signals a long-wear focus.
- Touring design targets a quieter, more comfortable ride.
Cons:- Not a substitute for a dedicated winter tire in severe snow or icy conditions.
- Touring-focused design may feel less responsive than the P Zero All Season.
- The provided details do not include measured noise or tread-life results.
Best for: Crossover and SUV owners with 235/60R18 wheels who want a touring tire for commuting, mixed weather, and extended tread-life coverage.
Not ideal for: Drivers who regularly face deep snow or ice, or who want sharper performance handling than a touring all-season tire is designed to provide.
- Tire size:235/60R18
- Load index:103
- Load capacity:1,929 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Tire diameter:29.1 inches
- Warranty description:70,000
Our verdict“Choose this Scorpion for 235/60R18 crossover or SUV use when touring comfort and long-wear coverage matter more than sporty response or severe-winter traction.”
Pirelli Angel ST Motorcycle Tire Set, 120/70ZR17 Front and 180/55ZR17 Rear
This is the motorcycle-specific choice in a lineup otherwise centered on passenger and SUV tires. The Angel ST front-and-rear set pairs a high-silica compound aimed at dry and wet grip with a directional tread designed for mileage and stable road manners. Its built-in tread-life indicators make it easier to judge wear than on the Scorpion SUV tires, which are not motorcycle alternatives at all. Compared with the Pirelli Diablo Rosso II set listed elsewhere in the roundup, the Angel ST is positioned for sport touring and year-round road use rather than a more sport-focused role. The limitation is that the supplied description gives no mileage figure, and its vehicle-specific fit means buyers must confirm both sizes and compatibility before ordering. It also cannot replace a winter-specific motorcycle tire where conditions demand one.
Pros:- Front and rear tires are included as a matched sport-touring set.
- High-silica compound is designed for wet- and dry-road grip.
- Directional tread is engineered for mileage and stable handling.
- Tread indicators help riders monitor remaining tread life.
Cons:- No specific mileage estimate is supplied.
- Vehicle-specific fit limits compatibility; confirm fitment before purchase.
- Year-round design is not a dedicated solution for severe winter riding conditions.
Best for: Motorcycle riders whose compatible bike takes 120/70ZR17 front and 180/55ZR17 rear tires and who want a road-focused sport-touring set.
Not ideal for: Riders seeking a track-oriented tire, a documented mileage target, or a tire set that fits a motorcycle outside the listed vehicle-specific compatibility.
- Front tire size:120/70ZR17 58W
- Rear tire size:180/55ZR17 73W
- Rim size:17 inches
- Construction:Radial
- Tread type:Directional
- Load index:58
- Maximum pressure:42 pound_per_square_foot
- Included components:1 front tire and 1 rear tire
Our verdict“Pick the Angel ST set for compatible road motorcycles when wet-and-dry sport-touring grip and wear indicators matter more than a stated mileage figure or track focus.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire, 245/60R18 (105Y)
I’d place this P Zero ahead of the Scorpion options for drivers who value steering response and cornering control in a 245/60R18 fit. Its asymmetrical tread is designed to manage cornering, while the compound and siping target wet and snowy-road grip; the pitch sequence also aims to keep cabin noise down. That makes it a more handling-focused alternative to the Scorpion All Season Plus 3 245/60R18, whose symmetrical touring layout puts greater emphasis on comfort and long-wear use. The P Zero’s listed 105 load index and 2,039-pound capacity also match that Scorpion’s stated capacity, but its tread depth is 10/32 inches versus the Scorpion’s 12/32. The product data conflicts on season labeling, so I would verify the exact specification before buying rather than assume its all-season name settles the question.
Pros:- Asymmetrical tread is designed to support steering response and cornering control.
- Siping targets traction in wet and snowy conditions.
- Optimized tread pitch is designed to reduce cabin noise.
- Load capacity is listed at 2,039 pounds.
Cons:- Listed tread depth is 10/32 inches, less than the 12/32 inches on the comparable Scorpion All Season Plus 3.
- Product data conflicts between the all-season name and a summer season field.
- Handling emphasis may be less suited to buyers seeking a comfort-first touring tire.
Best for: Drivers with compatible 245/60R18 wheels who want a more responsive all-season tire for road handling and cornering.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize a long-wear touring design, need clear and consistent season specifications, or require a dedicated winter tire.
- Tire size:245/60R18 (105Y)
- Load index:105
- Load capacity:2,039 pounds
- Rim size:18 inches
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:10/32 inches
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tire diameter:29.57 inches
Our verdict“Choose the P Zero for a more responsive 245/60R18 all-season option, but verify its season specification and skip it if long-wear touring is the main goal.”
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 SUV/Crossover Tire, 245/60R18 105H
For a 245/60R18 SUV or crossover, this is my strongest touring-oriented fit in the group. The symmetrical tread and 3D sipes are designed to support traction, handling, and braking across wet, dry, and snowy roads, while the 12/32-inch tread depth and 70,000-mile warranty description point toward longer-term daily use. Compared with the P Zero All Season in the same size, the Scorpion gives up some emphasis on responsive cornering but offers deeper listed tread and a clearer touring brief. It also suits a different buyer than the 235/60R18 Scorpion: the size and load index are larger, so fitment needs to match the vehicle. This remains an all-season tire, not a winter specialist, and the supplied information does not establish performance in severe snow or ice.
Pros:- 12/32-inch tread depth and 70,000-mile warranty description support its long-wear touring positioning.
- 3D sipes are designed to aid traction, handling, and braking.
- Designed for wet, dry, and snowy road conditions.
- Touring construction targets a quieter, more comfortable ride.
Cons:- Not intended as a dedicated winter tire for severe snow or ice.
- Less focused on steering response than the P Zero All Season in the same size.
- Fitment must match the vehicle’s required size and load rating.
Best for: SUV and crossover owners who need a 245/60R18 tire and favor comfortable everyday touring with all-season wet, dry, and snow capability.
Not ideal for: Drivers in areas with frequent severe winter weather, or owners whose vehicles require a different tire size or load rating.
- Tire size:245/60R18
- Load index:105
- Load capacity:2,039 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tread type:Symmetrical
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Tire diameter:29.6 inches
- Warranty:70,000
Our verdict“Choose this Scorpion for a 245/60R18 SUV or crossover when comfort, deep listed tread, and broad all-season use outweigh sportier handling.”
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 285/45R22 114H XL SUV/Crossover Tire
This Scorpion serves SUV and crossover owners whose vehicles call for the wide 285/45R22 XL fit, rather than buyers choosing among more common 18-inch sizes. Its 114 load index and listed 2,601-pound load capacity distinguish it from the 245/60R18 Scorpion, while the shared 12/32-inch tread depth and 70,000-mile warranty keep the model’s touring, long-wear character intact. The tread and full-depth sipes are designed for wet and dry handling plus all-season snow performance, with a quieter ride as a stated goal. The tradeoff is straightforward: this size is only useful when it matches the vehicle’s approved fitment, and the tire is not made for winter-only conditions. I’d choose it over the smaller Scorpion options only when the 22-inch specification and higher load capacity are required.
Pros:- 114 load index and 2,601-pound listed capacity suit vehicles that call for this higher-capacity fit.
- Full-depth sipes are designed to support traction, handling, and braking.
- 12/32-inch tread depth and 70,000-mile warranty description reinforce its long-wear touring focus.
- Designed for wet, dry, and all-season snow use with a quieter ride as a goal.
Cons:- Large 22-inch fit is appropriate only for vehicles specified for this tire size and load range.
- Not intended for winter-only use or severe winter conditions.
- Touring priorities do not make it the best match for drivers seeking a sport-focused tire.
Best for: Owners of compatible large-wheel SUVs or crossovers requiring 285/45R22 XL tires and a higher load capacity for everyday all-season driving.
Not ideal for: Drivers whose vehicle does not specify 285/45R22 XL tires, or those needing dedicated winter traction for frequent severe snow and ice.
- Tire size:285/45R22
- Rim size:22 inches
- Load index:114
- Load capacity:2,601 pounds
- Load range:XL
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Tire diameter:32.1 inches
Our verdict“Choose this Scorpion when your SUV requires 285/45R22 XL tires and you want touring comfort and all-season capability rather than a dedicated winter or performance tire.”
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 235/55R19 105V XL Tire
I’d put this Scorpion near the top for crossover and SUV drivers who want a single tire for changing seasons without giving up ride comfort. Its all-season compound and sipe design are intended to support wet, dry, and light-snow traction, while the touring focus favors a quieter, more composed ride over a sharper performance feel. Compared with the Scorpion STR, this model has a higher stated mileage warranty and an XL load range, making it a stronger fit for buyers prioritizing long-term touring use and added load capacity. Its 70,000-mile warranty is a notable advantage, but it is not a substitute for a dedicated winter tire: drivers who regularly face severe snow or ice should choose purpose-built winter tires. Check that 235/55R19 is approved for your vehicle before buying.
Pros:- All-season design targets wet, dry, and snow traction
- Sipe technology supports grip and handling across varied conditions
- Touring-oriented design aims for a quieter, more comfortable ride
- XL load range and 2,039-pound listed load capacity
Cons:- Not designed specifically for severe winter conditions
- The 235/55R19 size and XL rating may not suit every crossover
- Comfort-focused touring priorities may not satisfy drivers seeking a sportier response
Best for: Crossover and SUV owners with a 19-inch fitment who want comfortable year-round touring and a stated 70,000-mile warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers who routinely travel on deep snow or ice, or anyone whose vehicle requires a different tire size or load rating.
- Size:235/55R19 105V XL
- Rim size:19 inches
- Load index:105
- Load capacity:2,039 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Tire diameter:29.2 inches
- Manufacturer warranty:70,000 miles
Our verdict“Choose this Scorpion for a 19-inch crossover or SUV that needs comfortable all-season touring and added load capacity, but not dedicated winter traction.”
Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 102H SUV/Crossover Tire
The Scorpion STR is the fitment-specific pick here for SUV and crossover drivers whose vehicles call for a 245/50R20 tire. Its traction grooves and X-Sipe technology are designed to support grip on wet, snowy, and slippery roads, while the non-directional tread gives buyers a straightforward all-season option. Compared with the Scorpion All Season Plus 3, the STR has a lower stated mileage warranty and a standard load range rather than XL; the Plus 3 is the better match if its size fits and long-wear coverage is your priority. The STR’s 50,000-mile limited warranty and handling focus still make it relevant for drivers who need this exact 20-inch specification. Its fitment is narrow, and the listing notes it is not for sale in Arkansas, so confirm both vehicle compatibility and availability.
Pros:- All-season tread features target wet, snow, and slippery-road traction
- X-Sipe technology and traction grooves support grip and braking
- Designed for precise SUV and crossover handling
- Includes a 50,000-mile limited mileage warranty
Cons:- Standard load range and 1,874-pound listed capacity may not meet higher-load requirements
- Its 245/50R20 fitment limits compatibility with other vehicles
- Not for sale in Arkansas under the provided listing details
Best for: SUV and crossover owners whose manufacturer-approved fitment is 245/50R20 and who want an all-season tire with a stated mileage warranty.
Not ideal for: Drivers who need a different tire size, want an XL load range, or live in Arkansas, where this listing is not for sale.
- Tire size:245/50R20
- Rim size:20 inches
- Load index:102
- Load capacity:1,874 pounds
- Maximum pressure:44 psi
- Tread type:Non-directional
- Load range:SL
- Tread depth:12/32 inches
- Mileage warranty:50,000 miles
Our verdict“Pick the Scorpion STR if your SUV calls for 245/50R20 and you want all-season features with mileage coverage, but compare the Plus 3 if its fitment is approved and longer warranty coverage matters more.”
Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/55R17 94V Tire
Among these three, I’d choose the P Zero All Season for a driver who values responsive road manners more than SUV-oriented capacity or touring emphasis. Its asymmetric tread and high-performance all-season design suit luxury sedans and sports cars, aiming to balance handling and grip with year-round usability. Compared with the Scorpion All Season Plus 3, this P Zero is aimed at passenger-car performance rather than crossover comfort and heavier loads; the Scorpion is the more natural match for an SUV. The P Zero’s 9/32-inch tread depth is shallower than the Scorpion models’ listed 12/32 inches, a tradeoff buyers should weigh when choosing between performance character and a touring-focused design. It is not a dedicated winter tire, and the 215/55R17 fitment means it only makes sense when that size matches the vehicle placard.
Pros:- Performance-oriented design for luxury sedans and sports cars
- Asymmetric tread supports handling and grip
- All-season construction suits varied conditions without a seasonal tire swap
- Listed 1,477-pound load capacity for this passenger-car fitment
Cons:- Not designed specifically for severe winter weather
- 9/32-inch tread depth is less than the listed 12/32 inches on the Scorpion options
- The 215/55R17 size limits compatibility, and the listing includes the tire only
Best for: Luxury sedan and sports-car drivers with an approved 215/55R17 fitment who prefer performance-oriented handling in a year-round tire.
Not ideal for: SUV owners, drivers seeking a deep-snow tire, or buyers whose vehicle requires another size or load rating.
- Size:215/55R17
- Rim size:17 inches
- Load index:94
- Load capacity:1,477 pounds
- Maximum pressure:51 psi
- Tread type:Asymmetrical
- Tread depth:9/32 inches
- Tire diameter:26.3 inches
- Construction:Radial
Our verdict“Choose this P Zero if your sedan or sports car calls for 215/55R17 and you want a performance-oriented all-season tire rather than an SUV touring model.”
How We Picked
I compared the 13 listed products by intended vehicle and use first, separating car, SUV and crossover, and motorcycle options rather than treating them as direct substitutes. Within each group, I weighed the information available in the product names and specifications: tire family, stated all-season or touring positioning, size, and load and speed ratings. Those details help show which buyers should investigate a model, but they do not establish independent wet braking, snow traction, tread life, noise, or comfort results.
The order prioritizes breadth of fitment and everyday versatility, then distinguishes performance, touring, premium-positioned, and motorcycle-specific choices. The Scorpion All Season Plus 3 ranks highest because it appears across several SUV and crossover sizes in this lineup; P Zero All Season follows for drivers seeking a performance-oriented car tire. Specialized options sit lower not because they are poor choices, but because their intended use is narrower. I would verify the vehicle placard, owner’s manual, and manufacturer fitment guidance before buying any listed size.
| Pirelli tire | Tread type |
|---|---|
| Pirelli Diablo Rosso II Motorc | Directional |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | — |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Perf | — |
| Pirelli Cinturato P7 Touring R | Non-directional |
| Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Seas | — |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | Symmetrical |
| Pirelli Angel ST Motorcycle Ti | Directional |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season Tire | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | Symmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | — |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Pl | Asymmetrical |
| Pirelli Scorpion STR 245/50R20 | Non-directional |
| Pirelli P Zero All Season 215/ | Asymmetrical |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Pirelli Tires
Choosing among Pirelli tires starts with compatibility, not a model name. I would narrow the options by vehicle type, required size and ratings, and the conditions the vehicle regularly faces, then compare the remaining tradeoffs. These checks can prevent a common mistake: choosing a tire that sounds right but does not meet the vehicle’s specifications or actual driving needs.
Match the Full Fitment, Not Just the Diameter
A tire size is a string of measurements and ratings, not a single number to match by eye. Check the vehicle placard or owner’s manual for the approved width, aspect ratio, wheel diameter, load index, and speed rating. A tire with the right wheel diameter can still differ in width or load capacity, which can affect clearance and suitability. XL markings indicate a reinforced load category, but they do not automatically make a tire compatible with every vehicle. If you are considering a size different from the original equipment, confirm approval with a qualified tire professional or vehicle manufacturer. The listed Pirelli options span many specifications, so fitment should decide which models enter your comparison.
Choose by Driving Conditions, Not the All-Season Label Alone
“All season” identifies a broad design category; it does not promise equal performance in every temperature or weather condition. Think about the conditions you encounter most, including prolonged cold, snow, heavy rain, and hot pavement. Drivers facing sustained winter conditions may need a dedicated winter tire, even if an all-season model is suitable for milder weather the rest of the year. Also check the tire’s markings and manufacturer guidance rather than assuming the category label confirms severe-snow capability. The P Zero and Scorpion all-season names cover different vehicle classes, so their shared wording does not make them interchangeable. Choose for your local conditions and vehicle before comparing secondary features.
Balance Performance With Daily Comfort
A performance-oriented tire may appeal to drivers who value responsive handling, while a touring-oriented option may better suit steady commuting and longer trips. Those priorities can involve tradeoffs in ride feel, road noise, and tread life, but the product names alone cannot quantify them. Look for independent test data for the exact size and vehicle class if wet braking, noise, or wear are deciding factors. Avoid assuming that a higher speed rating means a tire will feel better in ordinary driving. The P Zero All Season and Cinturato P7 represent different stated roles in this lineup, giving car owners a useful starting point for weighing response against touring use. Match the choice to the roads and driving style you actually have.
Account for SUV Size, Load, and Vehicle Use
SUV and crossover tires must support the vehicle’s specified loads and fit its approved wheel and clearance dimensions. Compare the complete size and load index, especially for larger or heavier vehicles and versions carrying XL markings. Do not select a tire only because the model is marketed for SUVs: the Scorpion Zero All Season, Scorpion All Season Plus 3, and Scorpion STR are separate product families. Check the vehicle maker’s guidance for the intended use and approved fitment, and consider whether the vehicle spends most of its time on paved roads. A larger wheel size does not itself indicate better capability or comfort. Start with vehicle requirements, then compare the tire families that fit.
For Motorcycles, Match the Tire to the Riding Role
Motorcycle tire selection depends on the bike’s approved sizes as well as the rider’s use, pace, and typical roads. The Diablo Rosso II and Angel ST in this roundup serve different stated roles, so choosing between them is not simply a matter of picking one set with matching dimensions. Confirm front and rear sizes, construction, and manufacturer fitment guidance for the exact motorcycle. Riders who prioritize sport-oriented use should compare the model’s intended role with their everyday mileage and conditions; touring-focused riders should make the same check from the opposite direction. Replacing a set with an incompatible size or mismatched specification can affect handling. Ask a motorcycle tire specialist if the bike’s manual and the product listing do not clearly agree.
Compare Ownership Evidence Before Paying More
A premium-sounding product family does not prove a longer service life or stronger performance in every condition. Before spending more, look for independent tests in the exact tire size or a closely matched application, plus warranty terms and manufacturer maintenance guidance. Compare the attributes that affect your use, such as wet traction, ride comfort, winter performance, and expected wear, rather than relying on a single headline feature. Tire pressure, rotation where applicable, alignment, and prompt repairs also affect how a tire performs over time. If two options meet your needs, choose the one with stronger evidence for your priority rather than assuming the more specialized name is automatically better. Keep the total set and installation requirements in mind when comparing ownership choices.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Scorpion All Season Plus 3 the right Pirelli choice for every SUV?
No. It is the most broadly represented SUV and crossover family in this roundup, but the correct choice still depends on your vehicle’s approved size, load index, and speed rating. Some drivers may have a vehicle-specific need that points toward a different Scorpion family. Check the placard and manual before comparing model names. If winter conditions are severe where you drive, confirm whether an all-season tire meets your needs or whether a dedicated winter set is more appropriate.
Should I choose P Zero All Season or Cinturato P7 for a passenger car?
Start with the role you want the tire to serve: P Zero All Season is the performance-oriented family in this lineup, while Cinturato P7 is identified as a touring tire. Neither label establishes which one will be quieter, last longer, or stop shorter in your exact size. Verify that the available size and ratings match your car, then look for independent tests relevant to your vehicle class. If everyday touring matters more than a performance focus, compare the Cinturato P7; if responsive driving is your priority, investigate the P Zero option.
Can I use an all-season Pirelli tire through winter?
That depends on your local weather, roads, and the tire’s specific markings and guidance. All-season wording alone does not guarantee suitable grip in frequent snow, ice, or sustained low temperatures. Check whether the tire carries the winter markings required for your conditions, and review independent cold-weather tests when available. In regions with demanding winters, a dedicated winter tire may provide a better seasonal match. Do not choose solely on the assumption that one set is ideal year-round.
What should I check before ordering a tire listed in a different size?
Confirm the full size, load index, speed rating, and any XL designation against your vehicle placard and owner’s manual. Also check wheel compatibility, clearance, and whether the vehicle manufacturer approves that fitment. A matching wheel diameter alone is not enough to establish compatibility. If the size differs from the original, ask a qualified tire professional to confirm fit and any effects on the vehicle’s systems. The specifications in this roundup cover several applications, so do not assume a listed option fits your vehicle.
How do I choose between the Diablo Rosso II and Angel ST motorcycle sets?
Use the models’ stated roles as a starting point: Diablo Rosso II is the sport-oriented option, while Angel ST is the touring-oriented alternative. Then confirm that both the front and rear sizes and specifications are approved for your motorcycle. Consider your usual riding style and conditions rather than selecting by name or appearance alone. Seek independent tests for your bike category if grip, wet behavior, or wear is a deciding factor. A motorcycle tire specialist can help resolve fitment questions before you order.
Conclusion
For a broad SUV and crossover shortlist, I would start with the Scorpion All Season Plus 3, the best overall fit in this roundup because it spans several listed sizes. The best value direction is to choose the correctly sized tire that meets your vehicle’s needs without paying for a performance role you will not use; verify current fitment and ownership terms before deciding. For a performance-minded car driver, the P Zero All Season is the premium-oriented pick here, while the Cinturato P7 is the more natural touring comparison. Beginners should prioritize the vehicle placard and a straightforward, compatible all-season option rather than chasing a specialty model. For specific needs, compare Diablo Rosso II with Angel ST for motorcycle use, and consider Scorpion Zero All Season or Scorpion STR only after confirming the intended vehicle fit and use.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
